Meet Our Team

Leave No Stone Left Unturned

Paul Jack Fronczak
Founder and Co-Host, The Fronczak Files

Paul J. Fronczak is the inspiration behind The Fronczak Files and the driving force behind its creation. As a co-host, he brings listeners inside his personal journey, while helping others uncover their hidden truths. He is an American author, actor, musician, and motivational speaker known for his remarkable life story. Born in Atlantic City, NJ in 1963, he gained national attention when, as a baby, he was mistakenly identified as a missing child, leading to a decades-long journey to uncover his true identity. Paul is internationally known for his connection to the still open 1964 Baby Fronczak kidnapping—one of the oldest kidnapping cold cases in the history of U.S. law enforcement. He was found abandoned in Newark, New Jersey in 1965, and mistaken for the infant who was taken from his mother’s arms in a Chicago Hospital a year earlier. Given over to the Fronczak family and raised as Paul Fronczak, he took a DNA test in 2012 and confirmed a long-held suspicion—he was not the kidnapped child. When he discovered his real identity, Jack Rosenthal, he also learned he’d been born a twin—and that, more than a half-century later, his twin sister Jill was still missing. 

Since the beginning, Paul has shared his story with the world. He’s appeared on several major network shows including ABC’s 20/20 and CNN. He’s been featured in dozens of newspaper stories and telecasts. He has written two books: The Foundling: The True Story of a Kidnapping, a Family Secret, and My Search for the Real Me and True Identity: Cracking the Oldest Kidnapping Cold Case and Finding My Missing Twin. He was also featured in The Lost Sons, a documentary film based on his first book now streaming on HBO MAX.

Tracey Hastings

Co-Host, The Fronczak Files

Tracey Hastings is a Registered Nurse, Genetic Genealogist, and professional vocalist who co-hosts The Fronczak Files podcast alongside Paul Fronczak. With over 30 years of genealogy experience, including the last four years focused on genetic genealogy, Tracey brings a rare blend of scientific knowledge, personal insight, and storytelling skill to each episode.

Her 18-year career in high-risk obstetric nursing provides her with a deep understanding of the medical and emotional complexities surrounding infant abduction, adoption, and misattributed parentage—core themes explored in The Fronczak Files. As a seasoned stage and studio performer with 35 years of professional vocal experience, Tracey brings confidence, warmth, and clarity to the mic—making her a compelling voice in this personal and investigative journey.

Tracey’s unique combination of clinical expertise, genealogical skill, and creative talent makes her an essential part of the podcast, where she helps uncover lost identities and amplify stories that deserve to be heard.

Ashley Frazier 

Business Manager, The Fronczak Files

Ashley Frazier holds a Bachelor’s degree in Accounting and brings a sharp analytical mind and a lifelong love of puzzles to her role as Business Manager for The Fronczak Files. Her skills in organization, strategy, and problem-solving help keep the podcast’s operations running smoothly behind the scenes.

In 2019, Ashley’s life took a transformative turn when Emily Ripper helped her find her birth father and three half-siblings—an experience that sparked her passion for genetic genealogy and inspired her to give back. Since then, she has become an active part of the support community, using her skills to help others on their own journeys of identity and connection.

Ashley has developed a specialization in DNA mapping, a critical first step in solving genealogical puzzles and tracing biological family lines. Her mission is to provide others with the same care, clarity, and support that made such a profound difference in her own life.

Colleen Neuharth

Lead Historical Researcher, The Fronczak Files

Colleen Neuharth holds a Bachelor’s degree in History from St. Mary’s College of Maryland and a Master of Arts in Museum Studies from Johns Hopkins University. With a lifelong fascination for history, genealogy, and storytelling, Colleen brings a deep understanding of historical context and archival research to every case.

Her personal journey into the DNA discovery world began with a surprising result from an AncestryDNA test. As an NPE (Not Parent Expected), she understands firsthand the emotional complexity of uncovering one’s genetic truth. That experience sparked a passion for helping others navigate their own identity journeys.

Colleen is known for her love of obituaries, cemetery visits, and diving deep into old records—often uncovering the key details that connect the past to the present. Her meticulous research and empathetic approach make her an invaluable part of The Fronczak Files team, where she works to illuminate forgotten stories and help piece together family legacies.

Emily Ripper

Lead Genetic Genealogist, The Fronczak Files

Emily Ripper has helped reunite over 1,600 individuals with their biological families through the use of investigative genetic genealogy. She holds a Bachelor’s degree in Sociology and Anthropology, which laid the foundation for her lifelong dedication to understanding human connection, identity, and family dynamics.

Emily spent the early part of her professional career in the corporate sector, where she honed her skills in data analysis, strategic problem-solving, and project management. These strengths now fuel her work in complex genealogical cases.

In addition to her work as a case genealogist, Emily has been actively involved in the nonprofit field, helping to establish organizations that support individuals seeking their biological truth. Known for her extensive research skills, compassionate approach, and commitment to ethical investigations, she brings both heart and precision to every search.

As the Lead Genetic Genealogist for The Fronczak Files, Emily continues her mission of uncovering the truth—reuniting families, one story at a time.

Amy Morris

Social Media Manager, The Fronczak Files
Amy Morris is a registered dental hygienist, seasoned genealogist, and passionate advocate for uncovering biological truth through DNA. With over 15 years in traditional genealogy and five in genetic genealogy, she has helped solve hundreds of complex cases—driven by her own discovery of an unexpected parentage event (NPE).

That personal revelation ignited a deep commitment to helping others navigate their identity journeys. Amy believes everyone deserves to know their origins and understand their biological story.

As Social Media Manager for The Fronczak Files, Amy blends storytelling, strategy, and design to spotlight the decades-old mystery of Paul Fronczak’s 1964 kidnapping—and to amplify the ongoing pursuit of truth and justice.

Whether solving cases or sparking conversation, Amy’s mission is to help people find answers and connect the dots between past and present.